Kelly Clarkson and Brooklyn curiosity shop Art of Play are offering conflicting accounts of a shopping trip that escalated into a public dispute, with both sides now responding to each other online. The controversy began on Saturday, October 10, after Kelly Clarkson accused a store employee of treating her condescendingly while she was attempting to purchase an item.
Clarkson first shared her experience on X, explaining that she had driven to Brooklyn after seeing the store online and had several things in mind to buy. According to the singer, an employee appeared to question whether she could afford an item and offered to find something comparable instead. She compared the encounter to Julia Roberts’ character being dismissed by sales assistants in Pretty Woman, adding that the store had lost a potential major sale.
Your daily dose of music news, trends, and fresh drops.
InMusic Newsletter
“Wow, dude. You’re an idiot and just lost a huge sale,” Clarkson wrote, while encouraging people to visit Art of Play if they wanted to experience similar treatment.
The store responded on Sunday, October 11, through a statement on Instagram, identifying the item at the center of the dispute as “Molly,” a singing and dancing bird automaton used in the shop’s magic shows. Art of Play said the mechanical bird was permanently attached to the wall and was not for sale. The business also emphasized that visitors were welcome whether they intended to buy something or simply wanted to explore its collection of puzzles, games and toys.
Acknowledging the singer’s account, the store said that anyone who had felt judged while shopping could relate to the experience she described. However, it also highlighted the impact of Clarkson’s post, saying the small business had suddenly found itself facing widespread outrage from millions of people who had never visited.
Kelly Clarkson was quick to challenge that explanation. In a follow-up post, she insisted that the employee had explicitly told her the bird was for sale for $15,000 before offering to find a comparable alternative. She also claimed the employee had looked her up and down in a condescending manner, disputing the suggestion that the conversation had been misunderstood.
The singer called the store’s response dishonest and defended her decision to speak publicly, arguing that small businesses deserve support but should not receive a free pass for treating customers poorly. She also clarified that she had intended to make purchases, directly pushing back against any suggestion that she had simply expected special treatment.
“Your store is really cool. Unfortunately, you aren’t,” Kelly Clarkson concluded. She also shared a photograph showing a $15,000 price tag associated with the singing bird, adding another detail to the disagreement.
On Monday, October 12, Art of Play issued a second statement with a more detailed explanation. The store said Clarkson had spent approximately five minutes inside and that the $15,000 figure referred to a nearly identical automaton owned by the machine’s creator, Seattle-based artist Bliss Kolb. According to the business, Kolb was willing to sell that piece, even though the original Molly remained permanently mounted in the shop.
Art of Play added that it had offered to show Clarkson another singing bird automaton made by a traditional German clockmaking shop. Priced at approximately $2,000, that alternative could have been taken home immediately, the store said, but Clarkson left before seeing it.
The business also revealed that it had contacted Clarkson directly in an effort to resolve the dispute, expressing hope that the two sides might eventually laugh about the misunderstanding. Neither account has changed the central disagreement over how the price and availability of the bird were explained during the brief interaction.
Leave a Reply